AI 3/4 GUYS- 80's + New Amsterdam

*Paula looks very pretty tonight!

1. LUKE MENARD- very good, solid, not wow. He is SO cute, like a construction worker you keep driving by hoping it gets hot so he takes his shirt off and..oh I digress. GIRLY?! SIMON?! LUke is HAWT not girly! Simon seems in a harsh mood tonight already :(

2. DAVID ARCHULETA- He could do monk chanting and make it good. He's gona BE the next American Idol :D

3. DANNY NORIEGA- gag-off pitch HORRIBLE I agree w/Simon ;)

4. DAVID HERNANDEZ- his whole eyes/nose/mouth/teeth are identical to a girl I went to HS with named Cheryl so that kind of throws me every time. He is a good solid singer, makes weird faces. Why are alot of their tongues blue? Ending not as good.

5. MICHAL JOHNS- very natural on stage, perfect song choice, very cute.

6. DAVID COOK my home state MO guy ;) Lovey likes him. VERY VERY GOOD! I could see hearing that on the radio, very good vocal control, definite WOW factor!

7. JASON CASTRO- I felt he should have went home weeks ago BUT tonight was good, Im not a fan but I kinda like this one. (what song is this) wow Simon liked it :O

8. CHIKEZIE- he has tiny teeth. Not bad, just not my style.

VOTED FOR ok I didnt vote I was busy watching that new show New Amsterdam which was AWESOME more on that below but if I had voted I'd have voted for Luke, David & David.

GOING HOME please GOD Danny and I'd say probably Chikezie.

*NEW AMSTERDAM
Did anyone watch this? I was pleasantly surprised! I dont watch ANY network tv except AI and Survivor because of pure filth and dead body violence etc. but this show was GOOD I cant wait to watch more, It had several opportunities to go the way of most prime time crime shows but it didnt and the substory is awesome, more more more!

Ok, melzie monologue'ing over and out ;) xoxo melzie